What Is mutual fund portfolio overlap and how can you avoid it?

Mutual funds offer investors a convenient way to diversify their investment portfolios and access a wide range of opportunities. However, as investors allocate funds to multiple mutual funds, they may unintentionally encounter portfolio overlap, which can have implications for diversification and risk management.

This article explores the concept of mutual fund portfolio overlap, its potential effects on investors, and strategies to mitigate it effectively.

• Table of contents

1. What is mutual fund portfolio overlap?
2. Why Does Mutual Fund Portfolio Overlap Happen?
3. How can portfolio overlap affect investors?
4. How to Identify Portfolio Overlap Within Mutual Funds
5. Strategies to avoid portfolio overlap
6. Benefits of avoiding mutual fund portfolio overlap

What is mutual fund portfolio overlap?

Mutual fund portfolio overlap refers to the situation where two or more mutual funds hold significant positions in the same stocks, securities, or asset class. This overlap can occur when funds pursue similar investment objectives, invest in similar asset classes, or follow comparable investment strategies. While some degree of overlap is inevitable, excessive overlap can undermine the benefits of diversification and expose investors to concentration risks.

Why does mutual fund portfolio overlap happen?

Portfolio overlap in mutual funds happens when multiple funds in an investor's portfolio hold the same stocks or securities, even if they have different investment objectives. It’s important to understand this phenomenon to better manage the portfolio and avoid unintended concentration risk.

Reasons for portfolio overlap:

Limited investment universe: There are a finite number of publicly listed companies, especially large-cap ones. Many funds, especially those focused on large-cap or diversified equity, tend to invest in the same well-established companies. These companies make up a large part of major indices, leading to overlap, particularly with index-tracking funds.

Benchmark alignment: Fund managers often try to match or exceed the performance of a specific benchmark index. To do this, they may replicate the index’s holdings, which can result in overlap, especially if multiple funds track the same benchmark.

Sectoral or thematic focus: Funds concentrating on specific sectors or themes may invest in the same companies within those areas. If an investor holds multiple sector or theme-based funds, overlap is likely.

Similar investment styles: Even with different mandates, funds with similar investment approaches, like growth or value investing, may choose the same companies. Growth funds may pick high-potential companies, while value funds may select undervalued ones with similar traits.

Fund manager preferences: Fund managers may have preferred stocks or sectors based on their analysis and experience. If an investor holds multiple funds from the same or similar management teams, overlap becomes more probable.

How can portfolio overlap affect investors?

Portfolio overlap can affect the return potential on an investment, lead to redundancy, reduce cost-effectiveness, and potentially reduce the efficacy of an investment strategy. Here is a detailed look at the cons of portfolio overlap.

• Reduced diversification: Excessive overlap diminishes the effectiveness of portfolio diversification by concentrating investments in a limited number of securities. As a result, investors may be exposed to heightened risks, particularly if these overlapping holdings experience adverse price movements or economic events.
• Increased correlation: Overlapping holdings across multiple mutual funds can increase the correlation between fund performances. During market downturns or periods of volatility, correlated returns may worsen potential portfolio losses rather than provide the desired risk mitigation benefits associated with diversification.
• Lack of transparency: Excessive overlap may suppress the true composition of an investor's portfolio, making it challenging to assess the overall risk exposure and asset allocation. Without clear visibility into overlapping holdings, investors may struggle to make informed decisions about portfolio rebalancing or asset reallocation.

How to identify portfolio overlap within mutual funds

Below are some ways to spot portfolio overlap:

Review fund factsheets/portfolio disclosures: Fund houses regularly disclose their top holdings. You can find this information on their website or platforms like AMFI. Compare the top holdings across your funds to spot common stocks.

Use online portfolio trackers: Online tools and portfolio tracking platforms allow you to upload your holdings and analyze them for overlap. These tools provide detailed reports on the extent of overlap and show the combined weight of stocks across your portfolio, offering insights into your exposure.

Consult a financial advisor: Financial advisors can help identify and assess portfolio overlap using professional tools and resources. They can also guide you on adjusting your portfolio to minimize overlap and balance risk.

Manual comparison (for smaller portfolios): For smaller portfolios, manually comparing the portfolio statements of each fund is an option. By listing the top holdings side-by-side, you can identify shared stocks, although this can be time-consuming for larger portfolios.

Understand the investment objective and style: While not a direct method, understanding each fund's investment objective and style helps. If multiple funds focus on large-cap stocks or a particular sector, overlap is more likely.

Strategies to avoid portfolio overlap

To mitigate portfolio overlap effectively, investors can employ the following strategies:

• Conduct portfolio analysis: Regularly review and analyse your investment portfolio to identify potential instances of overlap among mutual funds.
• Diversify across fund categories: Allocate investments across different categories of mutual funds, such as large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap, international, and thematic funds.
• Focus on fund attributes: When selecting mutual funds, consider factors beyond performance, such as investment style, sector exposure, and geographic focus.
• Adopt passive investing: Passive investment strategies, such as index funds or (exchange-traded funds) ETFs, offer broad market exposure with minimal overlap.
• Rebalance regularly: Periodically rebalance your investment portfolio to realign asset allocations and reduce overlap.

Benefits of avoiding mutual fund portfolio overlap

Avoiding portfolio diversification can help investors potentially enhance their investment experience and return potential. Here’s how:

Enhanced diversification: Avoiding overlap can help investors achieve better diversification, spreading risk across different sectors, asset classes, and geographies. This reduces the impact of poor performance from any single investment or sector.

Optimised returns: Non-overlapping portfolios give investors broader exposure to the growth potential of different investments and market segments, enhancing return potential.

Reduced redundancy: Avoiding duplication ensures that the investment strategy is more efficient, with each fund contributing uniquely to the portfolio's performance.

Cost efficiency: Overlap can lead to unnecessary duplication of expenses such as management fees and transaction costs.

Strategic investments: An overlap-free portfolio enables investors to strategically allocate capital based on their financial goals and risk tolerance, rather than unintentionally concentrating investments in similar assets.

Easier monitoring: Managing a diversified portfolio with minimal overlap is simpler and more straightforward, making it easier to track performance, rebalance, and make informed investment decisions.

Conclusion

Mutual fund portfolio overlap poses challenges to investors seeking to achieve effective diversification, manage risk and optimise returns. By understanding the causes and implications of portfolio overlap, investors can implement proactive strategies to mitigate its effects and optimise portfolio construction. Through diligent portfolio analysis, diversified fund selection, and regular rebalancing, investors can navigate the complexities of mutual fund investing while minimising the impact of overlap on their investments.

FAQs

What to do if you identify an overlap in your portfolio?

If you identify overlap in your portfolio, consider reallocating investments to reduce redundancy and enhance diversification. Sell redundant holdings or overweighted positions and reallocate funds to assets or funds with lower correlation and greater diversification benefits. Always consult a financial advisor when in doubt.

What strategies work to avoid portfolio overlap?

To avoid portfolio overlap, investors can diversify across fund categories, focus on fund attributes beyond performance, embrace passive investing, and rebalance regularly. Conducting portfolio analysis and periodically reviewing fund holdings are essential to identify and address overlap effectively.

What are the long term effects of portfolio overlap?

The long-term effects of portfolio overlap include reduced diversification, increased correlation between fund performances, potential for higher costs due to duplication of fees, and limited transparency into overall portfolio composition. Over time, excessive overlap may hinder portfolio performance, increase risk exposure, and impede the achievement of investment objectives.

What is mutual fund overlap?

Mutual fund overlap happens when multiple funds in your portfolio hold similar or identical securities, reducing diversification and increasing risk. It can lead to amplified losses, inefficiency, and difficulty in monitoring. To manage overlap, regularly review your holdings, diversify across different fund categories, and consult a financial advisor if needed.

What are the risks of mutual fund overlap?

Mutual fund overlap introduces several risks that undermine diversification. These include concentrated risk, reduced diversification benefits, and the potential for lower returns. It can also increase costs through redundant fees, reduce transparency, and amplify market volatility due to correlated fund movements. Careful monitoring and managing overlap can improve portfolio efficiency.

Is mutual fund overlap always bad?

Mutual fund overlap isn't always harmful but requires careful management. It can be strategic when used intentionally, like sector allocation or a core-and-satellite approach, or when the overlap is minimal (5-10%). However, excessive or unintentional overlap increases concentration risk, reduces diversification, and leads to redundant costs. Awareness and monitoring are key.

Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.
This document should not be treated as endorsement of the views/opinions or as investment advice. This document should not be construed as a research report or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. This document is for information purpose only and should not be construed as a promise on minimum returns or safeguard of capital. This document alone is not sufficient and should not be used for the development or implementation of an investment strategy. The recipient should note and understand that the information provided above may not contain all the material aspects relevant for making an investment decision. Investors are advised to consult their own investment advisor before making any investment decision in light of their risk appetite, investment goals and horizon. This information is subject to change without any prior notice.